Decision Tree: Risk & Opportunities - Revision history

Tkokotas at 18:54, 17 November 2018

2018-11-17T18:54:01Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:54, 17 November 2018
Line 1:		Line 1:
			''Developed by Klavs Skovby''


	Uncertainty is a massive issue in project management and can lead to high cost and negative impacts if not handled correctly. The project manager must therefore be able to make the best decisions based on the information available.<br>		Uncertainty is a massive issue in project management and can lead to high cost and negative impacts if not handled correctly. The project manager must therefore be able to make the best decisions based on the information available.<br>
	First the project manager must be able to localize risks and gather information on the problem.		First the project manager must be able to localize risks and gather information on the problem.

Klask: /* Annotated Bibliography */

2017-10-02T19:26:12Z

Annotated Bibliography

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:26, 2 October 2017
Line 140:		Line 140:
	== Annotated Bibliography ==		== Annotated Bibliography ==

	~~'''Books'''<br>~~
	* Faber, Michael Havbro. "Statistics and Probability Theory - In Pursuit of Engineering Decision Support" Chapter 7 p. 143-154 <br>		* Faber, Michael Havbro. "Statistics and Probability Theory - In Pursuit of Engineering Decision Support" Chapter 7 p. 143-154 <br>
	**In this chapter Michael explains the usage of the decision tree and shows other examples on how to use the Bayasian prior, posterior and Pre-Posterior theory.		**In this chapter Michael explains the usage of the decision tree and shows other examples on how to use the Bayasian prior, posterior and Pre-Posterior theory.
Line 147:		Line 146:
	** In this chapter Graham goes into depth of managing uncertainty and risk on a project. The chapter has focus on identifying and how to assess the risks.		** In this chapter Graham goes into depth of managing uncertainty and risk on a project. The chapter has focus on identifying and how to assess the risks.


	~~'''Articles'''<br>~~
	* N Nayab "Disadvantages to Using Decision Trees" ,2011 <br>		* N Nayab "Disadvantages to Using Decision Trees" ,2011 <br>
	** For a deeper level of understanding of the disadvantages/limitations when using the decision tree. Here the major subjects are Instabillity, Complexity, Unwieldy, Cost, Too much information and Analysis limitations.		** For a deeper level of understanding of the disadvantages/limitations when using the decision tree. Here the major subjects are Instabillity, Complexity, Unwieldy, Cost, Too much information and Analysis limitations.

Klask: /* Conclusion */

2017-10-02T19:05:12Z

Conclusion

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:05, 2 October 2017
Line 136:		Line 136:
	== Conclusion ==		== Conclusion ==

	Without proper risk management every project is doomed to failure. It is ~~therefore~~ crucial for the project manager to understand and master the different tools of risk management to predict problems before they occur and handle them correctly. The decision tree is a great tool for the decision-maker but is also has its limitations and would not be suitable for every situations. Even though it is a tool that is easy to use. It require skills to know when and where it can be used without being a time demanding and costly affair.		Without proper risk management every project is doomed to failure. It is crucial for the project manager to understand and master the different tools of risk management to predict problems before they occur and handle them correctly. The decision tree is a great tool for the decision-maker but is also has its limitations and would not be suitable for every situations. Even though it is a tool that is easy to use. It require skills to know when and where it can be used without being a time demanding and costly affair.

	== Annotated Bibliography ==		== Annotated Bibliography ==

Klask: /* Alternatives */

2017-10-02T18:56:40Z

Alternatives

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:56, 2 October 2017
Line 126:		Line 126:
	<ref name="PMtimes" />		<ref name="PMtimes" />
	As project management is a discipline which is heavily dependent on the decision-making. There have been created many tools to help the project manager in the decision-making phase.<br>		As project management is a discipline which is heavily dependent on the decision-making. There have been created many tools to help the project manager in the decision-making phase.<br>
	Alternatives to the decision tree is the SWOT analysis which stands for Strength, Weakness, Opportunity and Threat. It bring unsorted issues to a conclusion using a 2x2 matrix ~~which focuses~~ on identification of internal (strength and weakness to the project) and external factors (opportunities and threats to the project)		Alternatives to the decision tree is the SWOT analysis which stands for Strength, Weakness, Opportunity and Threat. It bring unsorted issues to a conclusion using a 2x2 matrix by focusing on identification of internal (strength and weakness to the project) and external factors (opportunities and threats to the project)

	Another alternative is the Monte Carlo Simulation which is a method of probability analysis ~~run~~ with a number variables to determine different outcomes. This is typically a computer run ~~simulations~~ as the variables can have a huge range. When the simulations is done the decision-maker can plot the result on a probability distribution curve. Based on the shape of the simulations the decision-maker can then make the best decision based on the risk they are willing to take.		Another alternative is the Monte Carlo Simulation which is a method of probability analysis that runs with a number of variables to determine different outcomes. This is typically a computer run simulation as the variables can have a huge range. When the simulations is done the decision-maker can plot the result on a probability distribution curve. Based on the shape of the simulations the decision-maker can then make the best decision based on the risk they are willing to take.

	Furthermore an other alternative could be Pareto Principle which is know as the 80/20 rule. This rule states that about 80% of the effects are from 20% of the causes. Locating the 20% can therefore help the project manager be more efficient in decision making.		Furthermore an other alternative could be Pareto Principle which is know as the 80/20 rule. This rule states that about 80% of the effects are from 20% of the causes. Locating the 20% can therefore help the project manager be more efficient in decision making.

Klask: /* Limitations */

2017-10-02T18:54:01Z

Limitations

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:54, 2 October 2017
Line 112:		Line 112:
	The decision tree offers many advantages when comparing to other decision making tools as it is easy to understand and simple to use. However the decision tree also has its disadvantages and limitations.		The decision tree offers many advantages when comparing to other decision making tools as it is easy to understand and simple to use. However the decision tree also has its disadvantages and limitations.

	The information in the decision tree relies on precise input to provide the user with a reliable outcome. A little change in the data can result in a massive change in the outcome. Getting reliable data can be hard for the project manager for example how would you set the probability of a repair being a success or failure. ~~Thereby the~~ estimated cost could be way off if several events in a row has been estimated 10% wrong.<br>		The information in the decision tree relies on precise input to provide the user with a reliable outcome. A little change in the data can result in a massive change in the outcome. Getting reliable data can be hard for the project manager for example how would you set the probability of a repair being a success or failure. The estimated cost could be way off if several events in a row has been estimated 10% wrong.<br>
	Another fundamental flaw is that the decision tree is based on expectations that will happen for each decision taken. The project managers skills to do predictions will however always be limited. There can always be unforeseen events happening from a decision taken which could change the outcome of the situation.<br>		Another fundamental flaw is that the decision tree is based on expectations that will happen for each decision taken. The project managers skills to do predictions will however always be limited. There can always be unforeseen events happening from a decision taken which could change the outcome of the situation.<br>

	At the same time the decision tree is easy to use it can also be very complex and time consuming. This is seen when using it on large problems.		At the same time the decision tree is easy to use it can also be very complex and time consuming. This is seen when using it on large problems.
	There will be many branches and decisions which takes long time to create. With extra information added or removed the manager would probably have to re-draw the decision tree. <br>		There will be many branches and decisions which takes long time to create. With extra information added or removed the manager would probably have to re-draw the decision tree. <br>
	Having large project can easily make the tool unwieldy as it can be hard to present for colleagues if they have not been on it from the start.		Having large project can easily make the tool unwieldy as it can be hard to present for colleagues if they have not been on the project from the start.

	Even though the decision tree seem to be easy it requires skill and expertise to master. Without this it could easily go wrong and could be at high expense for the company if the outcome was not as expected. To ensure the expertise the company would have to maintain their project managers skills which could be expensive. <br>		Even though the decision tree seem to be easy it requires skill and expertise to master. Without this it could easily go wrong and could be at high expense for the company if the outcome was not as expected. To ensure the expertise the company would have to maintain their project managers skills which could be expensive. <br>

Klask: /* Application of the method */

2017-10-02T18:49:08Z

Application of the method

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:49, 2 October 2017
Line 77:		Line 77:
	The project manager wants to hire an external company that could do an investigation/repair on the generator for the price of $2500. The external repair company promises that they can deliver a repair which have a 90% chance of fixing the problem. <br>		The project manager wants to hire an external company that could do an investigation/repair on the generator for the price of $2500. The external repair company promises that they can deliver a repair which have a 90% chance of fixing the problem. <br>
	The decision table is now getting additional information and the updated probability can be calculated with this equation (Bayers' rule).		The decision table is now getting additional information and the updated probability can be calculated with this equation (Bayers' rule).
	<math>P''[\theta_1\|I_1] = \frac {P[I_1\|\theta_1] \cdot P'[\theta_1]}{P[I_1\|\theta_1] \cdot P'[\theta_1] + P[I_1\|\theta_2] \cdot P'[\theta_2]}</math><ref name="Probability" />		<math>P''[\theta_1\|I_1] = \frac {P[I_1\|\theta_1] \cdot P'[\theta_1]}{P[I_1\|\theta_1] \cdot P'[\theta_1] + P[I_1\|\theta_2] \cdot P'[\theta_2]}</math><ref name="Probability"/>

	In the table below are the chance of a repair to be successful.		In the table below are the chance of a repair to be successful.
Line 104:		Line 104:

	=== Decision analysis - Pre-posterior===		=== Decision analysis - Pre-posterior===
	The decision maker normally have the possibility to buy extra information before making his decisions (In this case it was the repair company)		The decision maker normally have the possibility to buy extra information before making his decisions (In this case it was the repair company)
	The information is worth buying if the cost is low compared to the value of the information. If different options to improve the decision are available the project manager must chose the option which yield the overall largest expected value.		The information is worth buying if the cost is low compared to the value of the information. If different options to improve the decision are available the project manager must chose the option which yield the overall largest expected value.
	With pre-posterior analysis the decision maker is able to facilitate if the information is worth buying or not.		With pre-posterior analysis the decision maker is able to facilitate if the information is worth buying or not.

Klask: /* Application of the method */

2017-10-02T18:42:48Z

Application of the method

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:42, 2 October 2017
Line 53:		Line 53:
	== Application of the method==		== Application of the method==

	~~Using~~ the medicinal company's decision problem an example ~~will be presented~~ with the use of a Bayasian decision analysis<ref name="Probability" />		In the following the medicinal company's decision problem will be revisited and used as an example with the use of the Bayasian decision analysis<ref name="Probability" />

	=== Decision analysis - Prior===		=== Decision analysis - Prior===

	To complete the decision tree information ~~as cost~~ of each stage and the probability of each event occurring must be estimated.		To complete the decision tree. Cost information of each stage and the probability of each event occurring must be estimated. This is typically done in the identification and assessment phase.
	For this case ~~the~~ extra power generator cost $15000 to install and the aftereffect of the generator breaking down cost $50000 <br>		For the ease there have been made some cost and probabilities for this case. The extra power generator cost $15000 to install and the aftereffect of the generator breaking down will cost $50000 <br>
	If no action is taken there is a 30% chance that the production is safe and 70% it is not.<br>		If no action is taken there is a 30% chance that the production is safe and 70% it is not.<br>
	By installing the generator the production has a 99% to be safe. With ~~really~~ bad luck there is 1% chance that both the generators break down.		By installing the generator the production has a 99% to be safe. With extreme bad luck there is 1% chance that both the generators break down.
	In the end of each branch ~~the~~ the expenses of each decision and events are summarized. ~~Therefore the~~ expense is $65000 for the path where both generators break down as the production will get stalled as well.		In the end of each branch the expenses of each decision and events are summarized. The expense will therefore add up to $65000 for the path where both generators break down as the production will get stalled as well.

	[[File:Basic2.JPG\|500px\|center\|thumb\|Figure 4. Decision tree - Prior analysis]]		[[File:Basic2.JPG\|500px\|center\|thumb\|Figure 4. Decision tree - Prior analysis]]

Klask: /* Method Description */

2017-10-02T18:23:36Z

Method Description

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:23, 2 October 2017
Line 30:		Line 30:
	== Method Description ==		== Method Description ==
	<ref name="PMP" />		<ref name="PMP" />
	A ~~situation~~ where ~~you could implement the decision tree~~ to ~~deliver~~ the best ~~expected~~ outcome. It could be if you are going to remodel the bathroom in your apartment and you are choosing between two contractors. Contractor A is the cheapest but is also known for having the probability of delays. Whereas contractor B costs more but have a greater chance of finishing in time. In both ~~choices~~ decisions and uncertainties are present in the terms of cost and delays. So which one do you choose? Obviously you would choose the outcome with the highest value or the one with the lowest negative impacts. <br>		A decision dilemma is where a person has to chose between a minimum of two options for the best outcome. An everyday situation could be if you are going to remodel the bathroom in your apartment and you are choosing between two contractors. Contractor A is the cheapest but is also known for having the probability of delays. Whereas contractor B costs more but have a greater chance of finishing in time. In both of them decisions and uncertainties are present in the terms of cost and delays. So which one do you choose? Obviously you would choose the outcome with the highest value or the one with the lowest negative impacts. <br>
	To better understand the problem let us say that contractor A will cost $35000 and with a 25 percent probability to not finish in time. Whereas contractor B will cost $50000 with a 90 percent probability of finishing in time. If either one of them fail to finish in time there would be a penalty on $10000. <br>		To better understand the problem let us say that contractor A will cost $35000 and with a 25 percent probability to not finish in time. Whereas contractor B will cost $50000 with a 90 percent probability of finishing in time. If either one of them fail to finish in time there would be a penalty on $10000. <br>
	Even with this small situation it can be hard to choose the best solution if no analysis of the problem is done. In larger projects there can be many decisions and uncertainties and many of them can be as a consequence of an other decision. It is therefore crucial for the ~~project manager~~ to have the right tools and be able to handle them. This is where the decision tree comes in handy.<br>		Even with this small situation it can be hard to choose the best solution if no analysis of the problem is done. In larger projects there can be many decisions and uncertainties and many of them can be as a consequence of an other decision. It is therefore crucial for the decision maker to have the right tools and be able to handle them. This is where the decision tree comes in handy.<br>
	The decision tree is a method to evaluate a decision making process. It is a tool that is commonly used within robotics, machine learning, statistics data mining and management. This article focus on the use within project management.		The decision tree is a method to evaluate a decision making process. It is a tool that is commonly used within robotics, machine learning, statistics data mining and management. This article focus on the use within project management.

Line 43:		Line 43:

	At the decision node the project manager has to take an active choice to move on. The event node is the effect that can happen from a choice taken. The last type of node is the cost/consequence which is the end result of decisions and events occurring.<br>		At the decision node the project manager has to take an active choice to move on. The event node is the effect that can happen from a choice taken. The last type of node is the cost/consequence which is the end result of decisions and events occurring.<br>
	Figure 1 shows the basic decision problem situation. It is a medicinal company that is investigating if they should install an extra power generator. If the power generator breaks down they would have to shut down production until it is fixed. A shut down could lead to massive expenses and on the same time investing in an extra power generator is also expensive.		Figure 3 shows the basic decision problem situation. It is a medicinal company that is investigating if they should install an extra power generator. If the power generator breaks down they would have to shut down production until it is fixed. A shut down could lead to massive expenses and on the same time investing in an extra power generator is also expensive.
	First the decision node is whether they should install the power generator or not. Both of the decisions leads to an event where there is a chance of two possible outcomes.		First the decision node is whether they should install the power generator or not. Both of the decisions leads to an event where there is a chance of two possible outcomes.
	[[File:Basic.JPG\|500px\|center\|thumb\|Figure 3. Basic decision tree]]		[[File:Basic.JPG\|500px\|center\|thumb\|Figure 3. Basic decision tree]]

Klask: /* Identification */

2017-10-02T18:05:20Z

Identification

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:05, 2 October 2017
Line 26:		Line 26:


	When the risks are identified and classified the project manager has many tool available to assess them. Probably one of the most popular ones is the probability/impact matrix. The matrix is a square where the project manager organize all found risk. The x-axis goes from low to high with the impact of risk. The y-axis is from low to high with the probability of occurrence. This is seen on figure 2. The risk in the top right corner is of critical importance and should be primary focus for the project manager. However in the lower left corner are of low importance and can mostly be ignored.		When the risks are identified and classified the project manager has many tool available to assess them. Probably one of the most popular ones is the probability/impact matrix. The matrix is a square where the project manager organize all found risk. The x-axis goes from low to high with the impact of risk. The y-axis is from low to high with the probability of occurrence. This is seen on figure 2. The risk in the top right corner is of critical importance and should be primary focus for the project manager. However in the lower left corner are of low importance and can mostly be ignored. The probability/impact matrix is a great way to organize and show which risk that should be focused on when taking decisions.

	== Method Description ==		== Method Description ==

Klask: /* Identification */

2017-10-02T17:50:45Z

Identification

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:50, 2 October 2017
Line 26:		Line 26:


	When the risks are identified and classified the project manager has many tool available to assess them. Probably one of the most popular ones is the probability/impact matrix. The matrix is a square where the project manager organize all found risk. The x-axis goes from low to high with the impact of risk. The y-axis is from low to high with the probability of occurrence.		When the risks are identified and classified the project manager has many tool available to assess them. Probably one of the most popular ones is the probability/impact matrix. The matrix is a square where the project manager organize all found risk. The x-axis goes from low to high with the impact of risk. The y-axis is from low to high with the probability of occurrence. This is seen on figure 2. The risk in the top right corner is of critical importance and should be primary focus for the project manager. However in the lower left corner are of low importance and can mostly be ignored.

	== Method Description ==		== Method Description ==