Challenges and opportunities regarding diversity within teams work

Revision as of 10:21, 9 May 2023

Abstract

A diverse team is a group of individuals with i.e., different backgrounds, cultures, races, ages, genders, and experiences that work together to achieve a common goal ^[1]. In today's fast-paced, globalized world, diverse teams have become very common in both schools and workplaces. Diversity within teams can bring both obstacles and opportunities. A diverse team can lead to a wider range of perspectives and ideas, increased creativity, and improved problem-solving. However, diversity can also lead to misunderstandings, communication barriers and conflicts if not managed properly ^[2] . Management of a diverse team is important, as it involves leading individuals with varying backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives. A good manager recognizes and appreciates the diverse talents, strengths, and experiences of team members and leverages them to achieve common goals. It is also important for managers to be aware of cultural differences and actively work to eliminate biases and discrimination ^[3]. This article focuses on what diversity and diverse teams are as well as how to manage those teams to achieve successful outcomes.

Types of diversity

Human diversity refers to the wide range of differences and variations that exist among human beings. These differences can be of many types, social-differences, differences in skills and knowledge, personality differences, differences in beliefs or values and differences related to work and community status, to cite several. These differences between various individuals within the team, do indeed have both direct and indirect effect on the teamwork and can play a critical role when it comes to decision making and problem solving. ^[1]

Social difference

Social diversity refers to differences in socioeconomic status, i.e. education level, and lifestyle. These factors can greatly influence an individual's experiences and perspectives, shaping their views and attitudes towards various aspects of life ^[4].

Differences in skills and knowledge

Differences in skills and knowledge can arise from a variety of factors, e.g. work experience, and personal interests. These differences can lead to varied perspectives and approaches to problem-solving and decision-making ^[4] .

Personality differences

Every individual has a unique personality that shapes their thoughts, behaviors and feelings. Personality differences can include variations in temperament, emotional reactivity, and communication style ^[4] .

Differences in beliefs or values

Differences in beliefs and values can refer to a variety of factors, such as religion, cultural background, and personal philosophies. These differences can shape persons worldview and influence their actions and behaviors ^[4] .

Differences related to work and community status

Differences related to work and community status can include variations in job position, income level, and community involvement. These factors can greatly impact an individual's experiences and perspectives, shaping their views on topics such as leadership, teamwork, and community engagement ^[4] .

Benefits

The benefits and advantages of diverse team.

Working in a diverse team can have many benefits that can improve productivity, creativity, and innovation. In a team of individuals with different backgrounds, each member has different perspectives and ideas. This can lead to a more innovative and creative approach to problem-solving and can result in new and exciting projects that may not have been possible with a homogenous team. Furthermore, diverse teams often show better motivation and members tend to become more ambitious to perform even better. Diverse teams often also raise/higher the quality of each individual, meaning one team member helps to improve other team members which may indeed allow the team members to be more productive in the future. A divers team also allows for a healthy competition within the group which can be used to motivate group members ^[5] .

Creativity and innovation

Diverse teams are often more creative than a homogenous teams and Innovative. That can be attributed to the different thoughts each team member has and their different perspectives, allowing for a wider range of ideas to be created. Diverse group of people are also more likely to think unconventionally and challenge assumptions, which again can lead to good ideas and innovative projects and/or solutions. Innovation and creativity have become critical components of success, in today's business world and working in a diverse teams can help promote these components ^[6].

(https://www.cipd.org/uk/about/news/managing-multicultural-teams/)

Problem-solving

Problem – solving is another skill that diverse teams often have. Diverse teams are more likely to consider all aspects and alternative, which leads to more thought out and creative approaches, making those teams more likely to find a successful solution. Having multiple voices with different perspectives, and personalities interacting with one another can engender out-of-the-box thinking, which can be particularly beneficial when tackling different problems. Overall, teamwork can lead to better decisions, products, or services. The effectiveness of teamwork depends on the different components of collaboration among team members.These components could be communication, coordination, balance of member contributions, mutual support, effort, and cohesion. If a diverse team has members who contribute to these components, then problem-solving should become better. REf( https://www.hult.edu/blog/benefits-challenges-cultural-diversity-workplace/ )

Minimizes discrimination and prejudice

Being with people that are in any way different from you, can broader one’s vison perspectives, enhancing understanding and reducing discrimination and prejudice. When individuals interact and work with people that have different backgrounds they often learn to respect and value the diversity that leads to behaviours which helps to create more equal and a better atmosphere ^[7].

However it is important that every team members has different background, because if the majority of the team members are from the same origin, speak the same language and have similar interests, the team may be too homogenous. It can be hard if one or few team members don’t speak the same language and do not relate to the others. that can lead to isolation and vulnerability ^[8].

Job satisfaction

According to a study from Bakhtar University , diversity in the workforce can have a positive impact on employees satisfaction and performance. Employees that work in diverse teams are exposed to new ideas, and new ways of thinking. Working in a diverse group helps employees to develop a broader understanding of their work, making them respect their co-workers more and appreciate their work. This results in employee’s satisfaction as the study showed that they had a better sense of belonging to the organization. Being happy at your work and in your group leeds to better performance resulting in better project and/or organizational outcomes. Promoting team diversity in schools or workplace can then be beneficial both for the people and the school or organization. ref(https://web.p.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=5d26c9d7-d25c-4532-b0e4-193f84bf343a%40redis&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#AN=131623676&db=bsu )

Challenges

-The conflicts and challenges that diversity can bring-

When people from different backgrounds come together to work on a project there can be many challenges. In order for teamwork to be successful the team has to reach its perfomance peak. That can only be done with the right team members. It is common that people with different background and different experience have different opinions that often can lead to conflicts or misunderstandings. This misunderstandin can be the result of a language barrier and/or cultural differences.

Communication barriers

Speaking different languages when working in group can be difficult and complex, as it can hinder effective communication, making it harder for team members to express their ideas and collaborate efficiently. It can encourage group divides and lead to misunderstandings that slower the progress and could potentially lead to project failure. ref (https://smallbusiness.chron.com/cultural-communication-barriers-workplace-13888.html ) og ref ( https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228596920_Language_Management_in_Multinational_Companies )

Cultural clashes

When working with people that don’t share the same values or have different opinions cultural clashes or cross- cultural conflicts are common. This often happens as people are unwilling to understand each other’s cultural uniqueness. If this is not managed correctly it can hamper the work environment as well as preventing synergy at the workplace or within the team. ref( https://ijol.cikd.ca/article_60478.html ) og ref ( https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323144035_Cross-Cultural_Conflicts_Concept_Causes_and_Elucidations_pages_79-96)

Application and management

- How to effectually manage diversity within a team and how to create a diverse team - Managing diversity in teams has become an important aspect of modern project management. With teams increasingly made up of people with different backgrounds, cultures and perspectives. It can be crucial to have strategies in place to ensure that everyone can work together effectively and effectively and to avoid group thinking within the team.Group thinking within teams can occur when conflict is avoided and the desire for cohesiveness is greater than the desire for best decisions. When a team is experiencing groupthink, alternative solutions will not be suggested due to fear of rejection or disagreement within the group. Group members will measure success based on the harmony of their group and not by the outcome of their decisions. One way to counteract groupthink is to have members of a group be from diverse backgrounds and have different characteristics.

Strategies for Managing Diversity in Teams

• Setting clear expectations and goals

It can be a good strategy, to create a team charter that outlines the team's goals, roles, and responsibilities. This can help guarantee that everyone on the team is working towards the same objectives and has a clear understanding and awareness of their individual contributions ref: (Project Management: A guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK guide), 7th Edition (2021))

• Encouraging open communication and feedback

Good communication is always important when working in teams (ref: The Standard for Portfolio Management, 4th Edition (2018)) When managing a diverse team, open communication and feedback is even more important and can be crucial. When team members feel heard, appreciated and respected they are more likely to be productive, engaged and dedicated to achieve a goal. Providing constructive criticism on each other team members work and behavior through giving and receiving feedback is another essential aspect of open communication. Encouraging open communication and feedback can build trust, encourage collaboration and help break down communication barriers that are common when working with people with different backgrounds. To promote this it can be good to i.e. - Regularly have team meetings with brainstorming sessions, where everyone can share their thoughts in a respective and nice environment. It is also good to encourage active listening by asking team members to summarize what they have heard and to ask questions to clarify their understanding, so that everyone understands and are on the same page. Finally it is important that the feedback is specific, actionable and respectful, whether from a manager or other group members. (need to put in ref)

• Emphasizing the value of different perspectives

Emphasizing the value of different perspectives is another very important factor when it comes to manage diversity. It is important to encourage people to share their experiences and perspective on a project, because a diverse team can have very different opinions and ideas on how they want things, this can be an advantage if managed right. By creating a respectful culture and nonjudgmental environment it can help members to feel valued when they share their ideas.

• Providing training and education on diversity and inclusion

To ensure that everyone is on the same level it is important to provide training and education on topics regarding respect, value, communication etc. Training and education can take many forms, for example workshops and/or lectures. This could be done both online or in person. The focus should be on providing a safe and inclusive environment by going over topics regarding diversity i.e cultural sensitivity and unconscious bias. This can help team members to learn and feel more comfortable in their work.

• Celebrating differences and promoting cultural awareness

It can be a good idea for managers to plan events to celebrate differences. That can be done by celebrating various international days related to difference . Another idea would be that team members have a short presentation about themselves where they talk about their background, interests, family situations, etc.This can help people feel more comfortable together as well as understanding eachother better.

• Addressing conflicts and misunderstandings promptly and respectfully.

As mentioned, working in a diverse team can sometimes lead to conflicts and disagreements. When Situations like that come up it is important to discuss the problem and get to the root of it. The PMBOK® Guide identifies Interactive Communication as one type of communication method. Using Interactive communication when dealing with conflict can be very effective as it is important that every person involves shares their perspective.

• Building a culture of inclusivity

Practical Applications

• Hiring diverse team members
• Providing accommodations and support for diverse team members
• Promoting teamwork and collaboration among team members
• Creating a safe and welcoming work environment
• Encouraging and supporting professional growth and development

Management Challenges and limitations

There are many challenges that can follow when managing diverse teams. As mentioned, language barrier can have a negative effect on group work, and it can be a challenge for the manager to make everyone understand each other and speak the same language. There are several ways to manage this, one could be to hire translators and interpreters, or provide language training program. However, One tool for measuring the language barriers has become poplar to use within organisations and that is to use the Linguistic Auditing methodology. The methodology is design to help organizations and companies to analyse and evaluate their language requirements and compare them to their capabilities to identify areas of both strengths and weaknesses. It is used to assess the company's language training and recruitment needs, as well as the effectiveness of these programs, allowing companies to match its foreign language competence to its strategic goals. By using these tools or methods any language barriers could potentially be avoided. ref ( Language_Management_in_Multinational_Companies-2.pdf )

Another limited factor could be to ensure that everyone has same work styles, as work styles can differ significantly around the world. That can create challenges for managers to establish a consistent work style, as in some countries there is more emphasis on working independently and it is more hierarchy structured while in other cultures, teamwork and collaboration may be more valued. It can be hard to get everyone on the same page since people are often reluctant to change. However, by developing shared set of values and expectations as well as providing training and encouraging flexibility managers could avoid or minimize the risks of clashes this could bring and create a unified and effective team. ref ( https://hbr.org/2020/01/how-corporate-cultures-differ-around-the-world )

Best Practices for Managing Diversity in Teams

• Engaging in ongoing evaluation and adaptation of diversity management strategies
• Seeking feedback from team members and stakeholders
• Continuously educating and training team members and leadership on diversity and inclusion
• Encouraging diversity in leadership and decision-making roles

Annotated bibliography

This article focuses on how to manage diversity, below are references that can provide further insights into the various aspects of diversity in management.

This article is about how managing diverse groups can gain a competitive edge. It discusses six aspects of corporate performance that  the management of cultural diversity directly affects, and that is  cost, attraction of human resources, marketing success, creativity and innovation, problem-solving quality, and organizational flexibility. The article also presents suggestions of how to enhancing organizational management of this diversity. https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/ame.1991.4274465

https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/34394

References

1. ↑ ^{1.0 1.1} T. Dippert, E. Gelles, & M. Merrick. (2016). Handbook of Research on the Facilitation of Civic Engagement through Community Art . IGI global.
2. ↑ V.Taras, D.Baack, et.al. (2021). Research: How Cultural Differences Can Impact Global Teams Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2021/06/research-how-cultural-differences-can-impact-global-teams.
3. ↑ J. Geraldi, C. Thuesen, & J. Oehmen. (2017). Doing Projects - Nordic flavour to managing projects. Danish Standards Foundation.
4. ↑ ^{4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4} E. Mannix & M. Neale. (n.d). The Promise and Reality of Diverse Teams in Organizations.PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST.
5. ↑ A. Stahl, (2021). 3 Benefits Of Diversity In The Workplace Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleystahl/2021/12/17/3-benefits-of-diversity-in-the-workplace/?sh=7990c45622ed.
6. ↑ F. Johansson, (2020). Why Diverse and Inclusive Teams Are the Engines of Innovation Retrieved from https://www.greatplacetowork.com/resources/blog/why-diverse-and-inclusive-teams-are-the-new-engines-of-innovation.
7. ↑ L. Holck, (2018). Diversity leads to greater social coherence and well-being Retrieved from https://sciencenordic.com/culture-denmark-forskerzonen/diversity-leads-to-greater-social-coherence-and-well-being/1454678.
8. ↑ How Promoting Diversity Helps Prevent Discrimination, (n.d.). Everfi Retrieved from https://everfi.com/blog/workplace-training/promoting-diversity-helps-prevent-discrimination/

^[1]

^[2]

Some references that I will use : https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/2158244019900173

https://reader.elsevier.com/reader/sd/pii/S1472811721000276?token=EA537F5D61C0115A5C474FD715F41A220FEBA61B6B9758B82265CB32810E609A70CA6C80C9E3BC0B3051A954AC6A217E&originRegion=eu-west-1&originCreation=20230212144832