Management with DISC profile analysis

Revision as of 22:34, 28 February 2018

Abstract

DISC (Dominance, Inducement, Submission, Compliance) analysis is a strategic tool for evaluating behavior often used internally in an organisation by managers to improve group dynamics and the well-being of the individual. DISC is a very simple and easy to use tool for improving relations, resolving conflicts, enhances motivation, and supports self-growth by obtaining a better understanding of the individual’s personality. Misunderstandings happen daily and can lead to stress, unhappiness and low working effort. DISC was created by psychiatrist and professor William Moulton Marston, who believed all humans have psychological motives but they differ from human to human. The tool assesses the level of Dominance, Inducement, Submission, and Compliance an individual possesses by referencing the norm. ^[1].

Relevance & Application

The relevance and application of the tool can be extremely broad. Wherever and whenever human interactions take place, synergies or tensions unfold. DISC analysis can be a tool for smoothing human relations if it is used right. In the workplace, the tool can be used by all levels of managers and employees working on a project, program or portfolio basis. For example, a management team that know each others DISC profiles can communicate better, shorten the time of their meetings, and prevent misunderstandings when they have the knowledge of the individuals behavioral profile. On the other hand, a manager can improve the well-being, communication, and working effort of the team. Developing the project team is a process of improving competencies, interaction between team members and the environment. On the figure below, the flow of inputs, tools and techniques, and outputs of developing project team are illustrated. Interpersonal skills, Recognition and rewards and Personnel assessment tools under Tools and Techniques all come into play with management with DISC profile analysis. ^[2]

Develop project team: Inputs, Tools and Techniques, and Outputs ^[3].

The DISC profile is a personal assessment tool and will let the manager know parts of own and team members interpersonal skills. Furthermore, the profiles will also indicate preferences of recognition. DISC is an easy tool for a manager to acquire the resources necessary to develop effective project teams.

This article will be focusing on the usage of DISC behavioral profile analysis as tool for develop project team.

Firstly, an introduction to the tool is given including the theory of the DISC model and its background. This is followed by the method of use including analysis and results. Implementation of results is outlined with concrete communication strategies for the different personal profiles. Finally, benefits and limitations are discussed.

Introduction

The DISC Model Theory

The DISC personality profile is strictly a measure of the individuals perception of themselves. All profiles are equally as good. The test results describes some of the psychological drivers which affects the behavior.

The general rule: Different = Different and not Different = Wrong

It assesses the behavioral level of the four traits Dominance (D), Inducement (I), Submission (S) and Compliance (C). Different variations of the DISC letters exist such as Inducement/Influence, Submission/Steadiness, and Compliance/Conscientiousness. However, the overall interpretation is the same. In the figure below the different characteristika is shown. ^{[4] [5] [6]}

Dominance (D)

The behavioral trait of Dominance is characterized as seeing challenges and seeking to overcome them. People with a high D are characterized as confident, risk willing, determined, result oriented and demanding. They focus on shaping their surroundings to produce the outcome of the desired results. These people desire to have power and authority, take on challenges, get direct answers, have the liberty of no control or rules, make changes, and new activities and the possibility of individual performance. The primary motive is taking control and be in charge and their major fear is losing control. They can be limited in lacking thoughts of others, being impatient, and lacking focus on quality.

Characteristics of behavior and needs of a high and low Dominance profile.

Inducement (I)

The trait of Inducement is perceived as extrovert and the aspiration of social interaction with others. People with a high level of Inducement seek friendly and favorable environments where they can have an impact in collaboration with others. In addition, they will try to influence and convince others. They focus on creating results by convincing and including others in a team work. The characteristics are optimistic, creating confidence, emotional appealing, involving themselves in others, extrovert, enthusiastic, charming, and open. Furthermore, they desire to be popular, being the center of attention, being praised, group activities, having positive relations, and having the freedom of no control or details focus. The primary motive is to receive recognition from others and they fear social rejection. Their limitations are being impulsive, unorganized, over promising under delivering, and lacking of follow through.

Characteristics of behavior and needs of a high and low Inducement profile.

Submission (S)

Profiles with a high Submission score seeks to conserve the surrounding working environment and keeping it stable. They focus on solving tasks in collaboration with others. Their characteristics are judiciously, reliable, collaboration oriented, patient and listing, loyal, caring for the group, and accepting. Their desires are authentic appreciation, collaboration, using known methods and procedures in their work, stability, and time when necessary to adapt to changes. Their primary motive is stability and they fear changes and unexpected events. Their limitations are putting others needs first and resistance against positive changes.

Characteristics of behavior and needs of a high and low Submisison profile.

Compliance (C)

The trait of Compliance is considered the urge for formalities, rules and structure. The behavioral characteristics are seeking to work within established rules and guidelines to ensure high quality and accuracy. People with a high level of Compliance focus on working under known conditions and to improve the quality of products and services. They are analytical and fact oriented and have awareness of standards and pay attention to details. Furthermore, they are very conscious, diplomatic, reliable and careful, and can often be a bit reserved. Their desires are being right, having complete overview, being praised for their tasks, limit risks, the possibility of leaning on authorities. The primary motive is to ensure quality and accuracy as they fear mistakes, sloppy methodology, criticism of their work and emotional situations. Limitations are very self critical, indecisive, and lack of creativity.

Characteristics of behavior and needs of a high and low Compliance profile.

Background

The history of the four quadrants DISC personality profile can be traced all the way back to Empodocles four elements of fire, earth, air and water in 450 B.C. Empodocles observed people seemed to behave in four different ways due to external environmental factors. 50 years later, Hippocrates redefined these as four internal factors called the four temperaments: choleric, sanguine, phlegmatic, and melancholic. Many years later, the theory was advanced further by Carl Jung where in 1921, Jung reconfirmed personality traits were internal and attributed the differences to how people think. Jung saw these four differences as: thinking, feeling, sensation and intuition. Today, these are often used in Myers Briggs Personality Test (MBTI).

The DISC personality was manifested in 1928 when William Moulton Marston published his book with the title “Emotions of Normal People”. The main principles of DICS have their roots in the book. Marston believed people’s daily behavior stems from their predictable characteristics. Their behavior was not only seen as internal but also influenced by the external environment. Marston defined the personality trait as: Dominance, Influence, Steadiness and Compliance. Based on Marston’s theory Walter Clark developed the DISC personality profile in 1940 which is widely used today. ^{[7] [8] [9]}

Method of use

Goals of Management with DISC

As a manager using the DISC profile analysis tool it should be sought to:

1. Understand one's own behavioral traits and tendencies and develop an understanding of how one's own behavior affect others.
2. Understand, respect, and value the individual differences on the team.
3. Develop strategies to improve cooperation.
4. Improve effectiveness in operations by advancing the relations with team members.

The Analysis

A DISC personality profile is created by answering a questionaire about the person’s behavior in various situations. The answers are subjective as the individuals are considered being experts on themselves.

The analysis is based on self-reflecting. When completing the analysis, the participant should picture themselves in a normal work situation. The analysis takes 15-25 minutes and consists of two parts:

• The Most and Least option for a group of 4 adjectives. In total there are 28 words to be considered. The 4 adjectives are proposed as main words and if unsure synonyms are giving as help.

• The Driving Forces Analysis part contains 6 questions with 7 statements each. The 4 most important statements in each question is ranked from 1 to 4 where 1 is the most important. 

The individual options choosen are confidential and not visible to anyone, it is only the combined results of these options that are presented in the personal report made.

Results

The analysis produces a profile report of 35 pages of the individual behavioral style, tendencies, needs, preferred environment and strategies useful for optimal behavior. Furthermore, it also provides insights on the strength and weaknesses of the individual. The DISC personality profile report evaluates the level of contribution of each of the four traits dominance, inducement, submission, and compliance. DISC can be considered as a “color palette of personality” where every person has their own unique blend. It is possible but highly unlikely to only have one of the four traits. Usually it is a combination as seen on the figure below.

Analysis of the basic behaviour and the adopted behavior is given.

Basic Behavior

The basic behavior gives a description to the personal profile of:

• What is natural
• What motivates
• How organising and planning is done
• How decisions are made
• How communication with others is done
• The consequence of the way of communication
• The value to an organisation
• Information for the manager on how to strengthen relationship
• How to increase efficiency in terms of types of needs and surrounding people
• The personal qualities

Adopted Bahavior

That adopted behavior reflects the changes you feel is needed in order to fit into situations. The adopted behavior gives a description of the following:

• How to approach difficulties and challenges
• How to communicate thoughts and ideas
• The response to the pace of surroundings
• The response to rules and procedures

Driving Forces

Implementation of Results

This personality insight can be used by managers providing them with a deeper knowledge of their team, group or colleagues that can be crucial for support, collaboration, and communication. Proactive measures can be taken by managers to place people according to their preferences of environment to help them feel comfortable and empowered. When approaching people, it can be done in a way that creates a positive response. It is widely believed in the community of psychologists that traits and situations are interactive. DISC can help managers adopting their responses based on the DISC profile of team members. This means managers should not always choose to use the behaviors that are the most comfortable for them and instead choose the behaviors that would be the most successful within the team.

When a manager believes to have a proper understanding of the DISC theories point 1) and 2) of the goals should come naturally. This section will therefore explore point 3) on how to develop strategies to improve cooperation. Questions to be asked are:

• How do the manager and the team members best communicate?
• How does the manager gain the trust of confidence of the team members?
• What concrete measures can the manager take in order to make the individual team members feel the most comfortable?

Assuming the manager already knows the DISC profile of the team members the task becomes What effective communication strategy can be utilized for the different DISC profiles. The following table provides an overview of how a manager should communicate with the team members of the four different behavioral profiles.

When completed accurately, the manager should be able to reach the goal 4) since team member relations are strengthened, the effectiveness in operations is increased. Improve effectiveness in operations by advancing the relations with team members.

Benefits

As a personnel assessment tool, DISC analysis provides a project manager and their team with knowledge about strengths and weaknesses. The manager can evaluate preferences of the team, on what grounds they make decisions and how they interact with people. Many tools for personnel assessment exist, such as Belbin's Team Roles and Myers-Briggs Type Indicator

Various tools are available such as attitudinal surveys, specific assessments, structured interviews, ability tests, and focus groups. These tools can provide improved understanding, trust, commitment, and communications among team members and facilitate more productive teams throughout the project.

The tool can be beneficial as a strategic tool on individual, team and organizational levels. It can be apllied on various needs of the company acspects of:

• Recruiting
• Individuel assesment
• Management development skills
• Talent spotting
• Optimization of teams and management groups
• Organizational development
• Change management

The questionnaire is web-based and fast to answer. It provides concise, clear and simple profile analysis. It is a international tool and translated into many languages making it highly applicable for global companies.

The key benefit of this process is that it results in improved teamwork, enhanced people skills and competencies, motivated employees, reduced staff turnover rates, and improved overall project performance.

Limitations

• The analysis does not measure all aspects of the personality

• The analysis is subjective. What you think of yourself is not always the reality or how you are perceived by others.

• Only tendencies are shown and it does not take the individuals values into consideration. A persons values are at stake and can cause a different reaction than according to the DISC profile.

• When completing the analysis, the least and most used options are not necessarily applicable and it can be hard to choose since behavior is flexible and dynamic and it can vary from situation to situation.

Annotated Bibliography

• Marston, W. M., (1928), Emotions of Normal People, Kegan Paul Trench Trubner And Company

Provides insights into the driving forces of human beings and the fundamentals of the DISS theory. Describes Dominance, Inducement Submission, and Compliance.

• Project Management Institute, (2013), A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, Project Management Institute, Fifth Edition

Provides the fundamentals of project management. Project Human Resource Management is described in chapter 9 and section 9.3 is specific about develop project team.

References

1. ↑ Marston, W. M., (1928), Emotions of Normal People, Kegan Paul Trench Trubner And Company
2. ↑ Project Management Institute, (2013) A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, Project Management Institute, Fifth Edition
3. ↑ Project Management Institute, (2013) A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, Project Management Institute, Fifth Edition
4. ↑ www.discprofile.com
5. ↑ www.discinsights.com
6. ↑ www.peoplekeys.com
7. ↑ www.discprofile.com
8. ↑ www.discinsights.com
9. ↑ www.peoplekeys.com