Revision as of 22:13, 25 November 2014

Review by NobodyKnows

I have gone through the wiki article and the review will be based from a chapter overview and finally an overall review. There are only comments if a section is shown below.

Introduction

• Very nice introduction!

Advantages and Disadvantages

• Very nice describing into multiple levels.

Advantages at team level

• A reference for the summary would be nice for checking copy&paste.

Advantages at organizational level

• A reference for the summary would be nice for checking copy&paste.

Disadvantages

• A reference for the summary would be nice for checking copy&paste.
• Please specify if the same disadvantages applies for the team and organisational level ?

Creativity in project

• A more detailed description of the figures would be appreciated.
  • maybe come up with an example.

Specific methods

• Nice and very readable.
• Maybe specify if this is also ways for implementing creativity in projects
  • Come up with examples or advices for this.

Overall review

• It is very hard to check references, due to lack of information.
  • Please add more information to the references.
• Some references are listed multiple times.
• Very nice written, but there could be added more to the article.
• Consider controversial points implementing this.
• Can you come up with other methods that promote this form of creativity - maybe design thinking?

JEPO Review

General

• Abstract is missing - A short recall of the topic, methods and results.
• Maybe a readjustment of the headings? Introduction has several sub headings which maybe is a bit confusing.
• Eventually ad a section about creativity in general and narrow it down to Creativity in organisations before discussing the advantages and disadvantages: Creativity definition, Creativity can be use in ...

• I miss something about how it is hard to force creativity
• Methods to increase creativity in a team or organisation: Workshops, Exercises, ect.
• How the working environment(office layout) or working processes are important element to increase creativity
• Eventually Best Practice of a creative work space (fx. Google, apple and other )

Introduction

• good introduction

Advantages and Disadvantages

advantage at organizational level

• "...requires a high level of creativity" but how is that an advantage. Maybe turn around and transform it to a argument, that with a creative working process it is possible to generate ideas in order to react on rapid changes"

Creativity in Project

• A bit general - still missing a little bit of how to generate the ideas of the diagram.
• Like the methods - but they are more like mind set, then actual methods